The Highway Toward Performance Improvement Is Littered With Fads, Fixes, and Flops

Have you ever wished there were just one business improvement model that would help improve performance in every aspect of your organization — a unifying strategy from top to bottom? Well there is. And you can put it to work for you for free.

Are you facing the challenges of becoming a global organization? Reducing cost and cycle time? Managing the use of more part-time, temporary, and contract workers? Does improvement in the value of your organization’s stock, operating income; sales, return on sales, employment and asset growth interest you?

Maybe all the hundreds of business improvement books such as “fish” and “moving cheese” have attracted your attention. And then there are other more complex business tools such as ISO, Balanced Scorecard, Six Sigma, and Kaizen. Which one works? Which one is best?

I have worked with hundreds of businesses and find all business owners and executives want to create excellent organizations, but many are unsure how to do it. What is needed is ONE business improvement model that helps improve performance in EVERY aspect of the organization–unifying strategy from top to bottom.

The good news is there is an excellent process available and even better–it is free of charge. The name of the process is the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award.

Consider Branch-Smith Printing, a 2002 Malcolm Baldrige Award winner. Branch-Smith is a small 70-person, family-owned business in the Dallas-Ft. Worth area. They began using the Baldrige process in the 90’s and transformed their business from a typical, family-owned style of management into a professionally managed organization generating excellent results that speak for themselves. From 1998 to 2001 they increased the number of customers from 91 to 167. From 1997 to 2001 they tripled their market share and during the same period increased sales by 72%. This is remarkable when other printing companies experienced decreasing sales during the same period.

Branch-Smith is only one of thousands of U.S. organizations finding the Criteria to be a significant tool for improving performance on the critical factors that drive overall success. Business, education, and health care organizations can all benefit from using the performance criteria provided in the Baldrige application process.

The Criteria provide a valuable framework for assessing and measuring performance on a composite of key indicators of organizational performance: financial, human resources, operational, and customer satisfaction. One applicant said, There is no better assessment of your organization’s performance available than applying for the Award. The Criteria for Performance Excellence are unique in addressing all the critical elements of your performance system.

Does the Baldrige process generate results or just another fad? A comparison of Baldrige Award recipients to the Standard & Poor’s 500 (S&P 500) shows that the 24 publicly-traded, 1988-1998 Baldrige Award recipients, as a group, outperformed the S&P 500 by approximately 3.8 to 1.The six publicly-traded, whole company Award recipients, as a group, outperformed the S&P 500 by approximately 4.8 to 1.

You do not have to win the award to benefit from the Malcolm Baldrige process. Working through the criteria and submitting an application offers valuable benefits. The feedback report that every applicant receives contains both strengths and opportunities for improvement – important inputs that can help your organization improve.

Awards may be given annually in each of five categories: Manufacturing, Service, Small Business, Education, and Health Care. Since 1988, 49 organizations have received the Baldrige Award, including Motorola, Inc., Ritz-Carlton Hotels, Wainwright Manufacturing, FedEx, and SSM Health Care.

Sixty-eight organizations have sent NIST their application for the 2003 Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award, the nations Presidential award for excellence. Last year, 49 businesses, schools, and health care organizations applied. Over the next six months, teams of specially trained examiners will evaluate these 68 organizations to determine which will receive the Award this fall by President Bush.

The 68 applicants for the 2003 Malcolm Baldrige National Quality award include 10 large manufacturers, eight service companies, 12 small businesses, 19 education organizations and 19 health care organizations. This is an increase in all categories compared with the previous year.

The application process for the Baldrige Award is rigorous and thorough. Applicants for the award submit up to 50 pages of details showing processes, improvements, and results in seven areas, including leadership, customers and markets, human resources and strategic planning.

Information about the Baldrige National Quality Program and the application process is available free of charge from the Baldrige National Quality Program website at 

Get started image

Ready to get started?

Get the expert support you need

Start Now

Related Articles

Save Yourself! How to Stop Being a Martyr-preneur

by Kelly Eckert, on June 04, 2023

Working From Home? Expect Sleep Trouble. Here’s How To Handle It

Richard Parker, on June 04, 2023


by Binnie Perper, on June 04, 2023

Five Tips for Creating a Great Team

by John Stob, Jr., on June 04, 2023

Retailers: How to Thrive after the Holiday Season

by Alan J. Zell, on June 04, 2023

Book Excerpt: Enlightened Power

by Linda Coughlin, Chief Administrative Officer, Cendant Corporation, on June 04, 2023

Start Your $0 LLC Today