Top 14 Search Engine Marketing Mistakes Etailers Should Avoid

Search engine marketing has proven to be an extremely successful and effective means of achieving online sales growth, but not all etailers know how to properly execute their search engine marketing campaigns. If you’re an etailer, here are some of the most common mistakes to avoid.

According to a survey conducted by Forrester, in 2011, online retail sales topped $200 billion. Search engine marketing has proven to be an extremely successful and effective means of achieving online sales growth, but not all etailers know how to properly execute their search engine marketing campaigns.

If you’re an etailer, here are some of the most common mistakes to avoid.

1. Having No Search Marketing Strategy – This may seem obvious, but all too often companies barely have a specific budget line item for search engine marketing let alone a strategy. Is the strategy to target certain terms for high natural search engine rankings and to buy visibility for the others with pay-per-click listings? Or is it to identify high-cost PPC terms and target those for SEO? What means of measuring ad-cost-to-sales will be implemented, and is this tool an end-to-end solution? And is there a realistic timeline associated with achieving these goals? Before spending time or money, put together a solid plan.

2. Not Doing a Thorough Job of Keyword Research (& Forgetting to Think Like A Searcher) – For each keyword that you identify for search engine marketing initiatives, there are probably two or three others that can deliver better, more targeted traffic. Misspellings, odd spacing, and product feature-specific variations should also be considered. And while some experts espouse a “more-is-better” approach to keywords, we feel this is not always the case, especially when you’re paying for all that traffic. Thorough keyword research can save money and future disappointments.

3. Not Establishing Performance Expectations Ahead of Time – Sure, everyone talks about ROI, but the reality is that there are many metrics that go into successfully getting a ROI and not everyone has done the “back math” to know what is even realistic. And if you launch search engine marketing campaigns without establishing benchmarks (e.g., do you really know what your max CPC could be??) and performance expectations, how will you know if you can continue your search engine marketing efforts as is??

4. Not Enough Testing – Setting up keyword campaigns without a testing plan is likely to result in unnecessary ad spending and poorer sales conversions than could be attained. You should be testing multiple factors: search terms, ad copy, match type, landing page content, offers, calls-to-action, etc., and there are a variety of tools that allow you to do testing: ad groups or categories in search engines, unique landing pages, and page optimizer tools.

5. Not Utilizing Tracking – The blessing and curse of the Internet is how much measurable data can be tracked and collected. For search marketing, treat this as a blessing and use tracking to optimize your efforts and get the most ROI out of the money you spend. Most web site traffic analytic tools still can’t put a price on the head of your average user, so you’ll need more sophisticated methods. Shopping cart, affiliate management and conversion software are some solutions; so is third party ad servers. Choose the solution that gives you the most usable data for your needs.

6. Not Attempting to Reduce the Prequalification Cycle – The less qualified your search engine traffic, the less likely you’ll be to make sales from that traffic. Instead of trying to optimize your site for broad terms which attract a lot of visitors but not targeted buyers, focus on terms and demographics that lead to sales. Apply the same strategy when buying PPC keyword listings, and use your ad copy to help weed out unqualified buyers. Don’t just rely on general search engines for qualified traffic either — go where your buying audience shops: on shopping comparison search engines like, and in vertical portals like travel sites.

7. The #1 Spot Isn’t Always the Best Location – Not only does the #1 paid listing cost more, it sometimes isn’t always the best one visibility-wise. For example, in Google, the top two paid listings may be “bumped” up above the natural listings and this location might be overlooked by the searcher suffering from “banner blindness” syndrome. Conversely, Yahoo lays out its paid listings from Overture quite differently — the #5 paid listing is actually at the top of the small right-hand boxes. We suggest testing to see what placement yields you the best results.

8. Establishing a Universal Max Bid – Yes, it’s good to have a max bid based on established metrics, but don’t unilaterally apply that max bid to all terms if certain terms are for products that yield you more net profit. Terms with greater profits can afford higher max bids, so adjust your campaign accordingly.

9. Not Setting Up Proper Match Types – It’s easy to overlook setting up and finalizing the best match type for your PPC keywords -match types can be confusing, tedious, and seemingly unimportant. BUT THEY’RE NOT!!! They can make the difference between a huge ad spend and a modest one, and ROI figures that meet your benchmarks vs. ones that don’t. 

10. Failing to Recognize the Importance of Dayparting – For some advertisers, it’s more wise to only run their campaigns at times of day or days of the week when their customers are more likely to be shopping. Doing so can help save money, improve conversions and cost less in customer acquisition. Daypart controls can be implemented using software tools so that it’s not a manual process.

11. Expecting the Search Engine to Close Your Sale – Sure, the search engine can send you traffic, but that doesn’t mean that where you send them is going to close the sale. There are so many other factors that must come into play once you get the visitor to your site: the messaging on the landing page, the offer, the call(s)-to-action, the quality of the graphics, product pricing (especially when compared to other sites selling similar products), shipping & handling costs, etc. If you do your job too, search engine traffic will be much more likely to make you money.

12. Forgetting Second Tier PPC Engines – You don’t have to rely on only Google and Bing. There are multiple other sites such as Facebook that may also generate sales at affordable (oftentime lower) PPCs.

13. Giving SEO Precedence Over the User Experience – All too often, companies become so obsessed with garnering top natural search engine rankings that they end up converting their web site into something garish-looking, poorly navigatable or functional, and with no clear marketing message. The end result is that they may have great rankings but lousy sales – don’t make this mistake!!

14. Not Considering Top Ranked Web Sites as Your Competition – BIG NO-NO!! The fact is that top-ranked sites, be they in natural results or paid results, get more traffic than unranked sites. Just because you’re a big brand company doesn’t mean that at the moment of search, your potential customer knows that you sell what they’re looking for or even that they’ll remember you. They’re going to go where the search engines direct them to, and therefore, those web sites are your competitors. Treat these competitors as you would your other competitors and get to know their strengths and weaknesses.

Hollis Thomases is the president and founder of, an interactive marketing specializing in search engine optimization, producing online advertising campaigns, and managing opt-in email marketing campaigns. Hollis has an extensive 16-year background in sales and marketing. Visit the website at

Get started image

Ready to get started?

Get the expert support you need

Start Now

Related Articles

A Little Brand Personality Goes a Long Way

by Donna Williams, on May 28, 2023

Social Media Overload: Does your small business need to be on every network?

by Ellen Williams, Regional Development Director, Constant Contact, on May 28, 2023

How Color Psychology Affects Your Sales

by Team ZenBusiness, on May 28, 2023

How to Identify Your Target Market

by Janet Attard, on May 28, 2023

10 SEO Copywriting Mistakes

by Karon Thackston, on May 28, 2023

Psychology tips to write effective cold emails

Marsha Kelly, on May 28, 2023

Start Your $0 LLC Today